housecarecosts

Sizing a tank water heater: first-hour rating explained

At a glance

Typical cost
$459 to $749 for a standard 30 to 50-gallon tank, unit only
How often
Each time a tank water heater is replaced
DIY or hire
Hire a pro

Unit price range is from Home Depot and Lowe's list prices for Rheem and A. O. Smith tanks seen on November 16, 2026.

Pick a tank water heater whose first-hour rating is at least as large as the hot water the household uses in its busiest hour. That is the rule in the US Department of Energy's page Sizing a New Water Heater, which was removed from energy.gov in July 2026 and is cited here from an archived copy (DOE, archived 2026). The tank size in gallons comes second. Two tanks with the same gallon number can differ by 20 gallons in what they deliver in an hour.

The first-hour rating is the number of gallons of hot water the heater can supply in an hour, starting with a full tank of hot water. The archived DOE page (2026) says it depends on tank capacity, the heat source, and the size of the burner or element.

Estimate peak hour demand first

Peak hour demand is the most hot water the household uses in any single hour of the day. The archived DOE page (2026) gives a worksheet for it: pick the busiest hour, count each use in that hour, and multiply by the average gallons per use.

Hot water useAverage gallons per use
Shower20
Shaving2
Hand dishwashing or food prep3
Automatic dishwasher7
Clothes washer, top-loader25
Clothes washer, H-axis15

Source: US Department of Energy, Sizing a New Water Heater, archived copy of July 2, 2026. DOE notes these are averages gathered from published information, and that the worksheet does not estimate total daily use.

Three sample households, added up from those figures:

  • Two showers and one dishwasher load in the same hour: 47 gallons.
  • Three showers, one shave and one round of hand dishwashing: 65 gallons.
  • Three showers and one top-loader wash: 85 gallons.

The second line is DOE's own example. The archived page prints its total as 66 gallons, but the lines it shows (60, 2 and 3) add to 65. The one-gallon gap does not change which heater fits.

To skip the arithmetic, the water heater sizing calculator runs the same worksheet.

Why tank gallons alone mislead

A tank delivers its stored hot water plus whatever the burner or elements reheat during the hour. A bigger burner or element adds more in that hour, so the rating moves with heat input as much as with tank size. Rheem's specification sheets for its Performance line show how far the two numbers drift apart.

  • Same gallons, different element. Rheem (2020 spec sheet) lists a 30-gallon short electric tank with 4,500-watt elements at a first-hour rating of 46 gallons. The same tank with 3,800-watt elements is rated 33 gallons.
  • Same gallons, different fuel. A 40-gallon tall electric tank is rated 54 gallons (Rheem, 2020 spec sheet). A 40-gallon tall natural gas tank with a 36,000 BTU burner is rated 68 gallons (Rheem, 2023 spec sheet).
  • Same gallons and fuel, different model. Rheem's 40-gallon natural gas tanks run from 64 to 84 gallons across the 2023 sheet.
  • A 40 that beats a 50. On that sheet, the 40-gallon tall high-efficiency model XG40T06TH40U0 is rated 84 gallons, and the 50-gallon tall high-efficiency model XG50T06HE40U0 is rated 77 gallons. Both have 40,000 BTU burners.

Recovery explains the fuel gap. The Rheem sheets give 21 gallons per hour at a 90-degree rise for 4,500-watt electric models and 36.4 gallons per hour for the 36,000 BTU gas model.

The gallon number on the box is also a nominal figure. Rheem (2020 spec sheet) lists its 50-gallon electric tanks with a rated capacity of 45 gallons under Department of Energy requirements.

Match peak hour demand to a rating

Find the household's peak hour demand in the left column, then shop for the rating in the second column or higher. The example models are ones with a published rating read for this article. Any brand with the same or a higher rating meets the DOE rule.

Peak hour demandFirst-hour rating to look forExample model and its ratingFederal draw pattern at that rating
Up to 45 gallons45 gallons or moreRheem XE30M06ST45U1, 30-gallon electric: 45Low
46 to 54 gallons54 gallons or moreRheem XE40T06ST45U1, 40-gallon electric: 54Medium
55 to 61 gallons61 gallons or moreRheem XE50T06ST45U1, 50-gallon electric: 61Medium
62 to 68 gallons68 gallons or moreRheem XG40T06EC36U1, 40-gallon gas: 68Medium
69 to 85 gallons85 gallons or moreRheem XG50T06EC38U1, 50-gallon gas: 85. A. O. Smith G6N-T5040NVR, 50-gallon gas: 81High
86 to 97 gallons97 gallons or moreRheem XG55T06EC50U0, 55-gallon gas: 97High
More than 97 gallonsAbove the standard models read for this articleAsk a licensed plumber about a higher-input or different type of heaterHigh

Sources: ratings from Rheem Performance spec sheets dated 08/20 (electric) and 12/23 (gas), and a Lowe's listing for the A. O. Smith model seen on November 16, 2026. Draw patterns apply the thresholds in 10 CFR Part 430, Subpart B, Appendix E to each rating.

The electric rows stop at 61 gallons because that is the highest rating on the Rheem electric sheet, which covers tanks up to 50 gallons. A household above that figure with electric service needs a larger or different electric model than the ones read here, and its rating should be checked the same way.

Where the rating is printed

  • EnergyGuide label. The archived DOE page (2026) says the yellow label lists the number in the top left corner as "Capacity (first hour rating)." The Federal Trade Commission (2026) lists water heaters among the appliances that carry the label. The DOE section describing the label is dated 2012, so the layout on a new unit may differ.
  • Manufacturer specification sheet. Rheem's sheets have a "First Hour Rating" column beside each model number. The Rheem product page for the XG40T06EC36U1 (2026) shows only a range for the whole series, 55 to 97 gallons, so open the spec sheet linked from the page to get the figure for one model.
  • Retail listing. The Lowe's listing for the A. O. Smith G6N-T5040NVR (2026) states the rating in the product description, at 81 gallons in the first hour.
  • AHRI directory. The Rheem sheets carry the AHRI Certified mark, and AHRI keeps an online directory of certified ratings. That directory could not be opened for this article, so no figure here comes from it.

Match the full model number. One or two characters can separate two tanks with different ratings.

How the federal draw-pattern bins connect to the rating

The rating is a lab result. Under the federal test procedure in 10 CFR Part 430, Subpart B, Appendix E (read in 2026 from Cornell's Legal Information Institute copy), a fully heated tank of 20 gallons or more is drawn at 3.0 gallons per minute. Each draw stops when the outlet temperature falls 15 degrees Fahrenheit below its peak, and draws repeat for one hour. The regulation defines the first-hour rating as an estimate of the maximum volume of hot water the heater can supply in an hour that begins with the heater fully heated.

That rating then decides which daily draw pattern is used to measure the heater's uniform energy factor, or UEF.

First-hour ratingDraw patternHot water drawn in the 24-hour UEF test
Less than 18 gallonsVery small usage10 gallons
18 to less than 51 gallonsLow usage38 gallons
51 to less than 75 gallonsMedium usage55 gallons
75 gallons or moreHigh usage84 gallons

Source: 10 CFR Part 430, Subpart B, Appendix E, as read on November 16, 2026.

Two things follow for a buyer. First, a UEF is measured under the bin the heater lands in, so compare UEF only between heaters in the same bin. Second, the bin names describe the test, not the household. A home with a 65-gallon peak hour belongs with medium-usage models whether or not it thinks of itself as a medium user.

ENERGY STAR's water heater criteria (undated, read in 2026) use the same terms. Certified gas storage heaters need a first-hour rating of at least 51 gallons, and certified electric storage heaters need at least 45. For gas tanks over 20 and up to 55 gallons, the minimum UEF is 0.81 in the medium draw pattern and 0.86 in the high draw pattern.

What standard tanks cost in November 2026

These are list prices for the heater alone, seen on November 16, 2026, on one store's online listing at each retailer. Prices can differ by location, and installation is extra.

ModelTank and fuelFirst-hour ratingPriceSeller
Rheem XE30M06ST45U130-gallon electric45$459Home Depot
Rheem XE40M06ST45U140-gallon electric53$469Home Depot
Rheem XE40T06ST45U140-gallon electric54$499Home Depot
Rheem XE50T06ST45U150-gallon electric61$599Home Depot
Rheem XG40T06EC36U140-gallon natural gas68$649Home Depot
Rheem XG50T06EC38U150-gallon natural gas85$749Home Depot
A. O. Smith G6N-T5040NVR50-gallon natural gas81$749Lowe's

Ratings are from the Rheem spec sheets and the Lowe's listing cited above. On these listings, 8 more gallons of first-hour rating in electric, from 53 to 61, cost $130. In gas, 17 more gallons, from 68 to 85, cost $100.

Replacing a water heater involves gas piping, venting or 240-volt wiring, and a temperature and pressure relief valve. Hire a licensed plumber for the installation, and ask the local building department whether a permit is required.

What to check before buying

  • Work out peak hour demand for the household as it is now, and again for any change already planned, such as another person moving in.
  • Read the first-hour rating for the exact model number on the EnergyGuide label or the manufacturer's spec sheet. Do not rely on the gallon size in the product name.
  • Confirm the fuel and the heat input. The Rheem sheets (2020, 2023) show that element wattage and burner size change the rating on tanks of the same size.
  • Compare UEF only between models in the same draw pattern.
  • Measure the space. The Rheem sheets list tall, medium and short versions of the same gallon size with different heights and diameters, and the ratings differ between them. The 40-gallon short gas model is rated 64 gallons and the 40-gallon tall is rated 68.
  • If the rating that matches peak demand is not available in the fuel the home has, ask the plumber to quote the options before settling for a lower rating.

Work out your own numbers

Water heater sizingLive
Your busiest hour of hot water

Result

65 gallons or more

Peak hour demand is 65 gallons. Look for a tank with a first-hour rating of at least 65 gallons.

An estimate based on average figures, for storage tank and heat pump water heaters with a tank. It does not size a tankless water heater and does not replace a plumber's assessment.

Sources

  1. US Department of Energy, Sizing a New Water Heater (archived copy of July 2, 2026). Accessed November 16, 2026.
  2. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 10 CFR Part 430 Subpart B Appendix E, Uniform Test Method for Measuring the Energy Consumption of Water Heaters. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  3. ENERGY STAR, Residential Water Heaters Key Product Criteria. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  4. Federal Trade Commission, How To Use the EnergyGuide Label To Shop for Home Appliances. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  5. Rheem, Performance electric water heater specification sheet, form THD-PE06 N Rev. 6 (08/20). Accessed November 16, 2026.
  6. Rheem, Performance atmospheric gas water heater specification sheet, form THD-PGRH N Rev. 12 (12/23). Accessed November 16, 2026.
  7. Rheem, Performance Series Atmospheric XG40T06EC36U1 product page. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  8. Lowe's, A. O. Smith Signature 100 50-gallon tall natural gas water heater G6N-T5040NVR listing and price. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  9. Lowe's, A. O. Smith Signature 100 50-gallon water heater listings and prices. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  10. Home Depot, Rheem Performance 40-gallon and 50-gallon electric water heater listings and prices. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  11. Home Depot, Rheem Performance 50-gallon natural gas water heater listings and prices. Accessed November 16, 2026.
  12. Home Depot, Rheem Performance 30-gallon water heater listings and prices. Accessed November 16, 2026.